Diff for "RFC_1/RFC1_Comment_API"

Describe RFC 1/RFC1 Comment API here.

IlianaAvila -9/30/05- I put in this new comment section, since I had additional comments that did not fit in any existent category.

IlianaAvila -9/30/05- I think we also need:

/**
 * Deletes the given attribute completely for all objects
 */ 
boolean deleteAttribute (String attributeName);

The implementation for this method can be more efficient than calling deleteAttribute (String id, String attributeName) for all ids. But I don't know how attributes are stored, so maybe it would be the same.

NeriusLandys -9/30/05- See CyDataDefinition.undefineAttribute(String).

IlianaAvila -9/30/05- I think the method should be in CyAttributes, and called deleteAttribute(String). The name undefineAttribute seems strange.

IlianaAvila -9/30/05- I am not sure that I like to have the additional CyData and CyDataDefinition interfaces. I like the idea of having one single interface to handle attributes for Cytoscape. What additional methods do these interfaces have? Are they really going to be used? Could we put the needed ones in CyAttributes?

NeriusLandys -9/30/05- I think Ethan's API is fairly intuitive and would definitely be a cinch to implement.

GaryBader - 9/30/05 - If we add deleteAttribute to permanently remove an attribute from Cytoscape, which I think we would, I think the deleteAttribute method that is in Ethan's current proposal should be called clearAttribute.

EthanCerami - 10/1/05 - I think Iliana's suggestion re: deleteAttribute(String attributeName) is a good one, and I think this is currently available via GraphObjAttributes. However, having one method called clearAttribute and one called deleteAttribute seems a bit confusing. I think they should both be named deleteAttribute(), e.g. deleteAttribute (String id, String attributeName) and deleteAttribute (String attributeName).

GaryBader - 10/1/05 - Good point. It seems that we use the word 'attributes' for a set of attributes in the manual, and 'attribute' for just one attribute. So deleteAttribute (String attributeName) should probably be deleteAttributes (String attributeName)